The Instant Pot is basically a tiny countertop wizard: it can turn dried beans into dinner, rescue you from
“I forgot to thaw the chicken,” and make rice without you hovering like a nervous sitcom parent.
But it also has one weakness: humans. Specifically, humans who treat it like a regular pot with extra buttons.
If you’ve ever stared at the display while it smugly says “ON” forever, gotten a surprise
Burn message, or opened the lid to find soup that tastes like “warm water with vibes,” you’re
not alone. Below are seven common Instant Pot mistakesplus exactly how to dodge themso your next meal is
delicious, not dramatic.
1) Mistake: Thinking the “Cook Time” Is the Total Time
This one is the Instant Pot classic: you set 8 minutes for chicken, tell everyone dinner is in
ten, and then the pot spends 15 minutes building pressure like it’s getting emotionally ready for commitment.
Why it happens
- Preheat/pressurize time happens before the countdown begins.
- Release time (quick or natural) adds more minutes after cooking ends.
- The fuller the pot (or the colder the ingredients), the longer the warm-up.
How to avoid it
- Plan for a simple “Instant Pot math” estimate:
pressurize (5–20 min) + cook time + release (2–20+ min). - For weeknights, pick recipes with predictable release (like quick-release vegetables) or start earlier and relax.
The pot is fast, but it’s not a time machine. - If timing is tight, cut ingredients smaller (faster heat-up), use room-temp liquid, and avoid packing the pot to the brim.
2) Mistake: Not Sealing Properly (The Valve, the Ring, or Both)
If your Instant Pot won’t come to pressure, chances are it’s not broken. It’s just… not sealed. Like a jar with a
crooked lid. Like your phone screen protector. Like the emotional defenses of a cat.
Why it happens
- The steam release valve is set to venting instead of sealing.
- The silicone sealing ring isn’t seated correctlyor got left on the counter after washing.
- Food debris is stuck around the sealing area or the float valve.
How to avoid it
- Do a 5-second preflight check before every pressure cook:
Ring in? Valve set to seal? Lid locked? - After cleaning, press the ring firmly into place and run your finger around it to make sure it’s evenly seated.
- Keep the lid parts cleanespecially the float valve areaso the pot can detect pressure correctly.
- Safety note: never force the lid open. If it won’t open, it’s still pressurized or still hot.
3) Mistake: Using Too Little Liquid (Or the Wrong Kind of Liquid)
Pressure cooking needs steam. Steam needs thin, water-based liquid. If you don’t add enough, the pot can’t
pressurize properlyand it may overheat the bottom and throw a Burn warning.
Why it happens
- Some recipes online underestimate liquid (or assume you’re using a different model/size).
- People try to swap broth for oil, or use only thick sauces (spoiler: steam does not come from olive oil).
- The pot needs circulation; thick liquids don’t move heat well at the bottom.
How to avoid it
- Follow your model’s manual for minimum liquid. As a practical rule, aim for
at least 1 to 2 cups of thin, water-based liquid unless a trusted recipe says otherwise.
(Different sizes and models varyyour manual wins.) - Use thin liquids for pressure cooking: water, broth, stock, diluted sauces, juice, wine + broth.
- If you’re adapting a stovetop recipe, add liquid and reduce later using sauté mode.
Special case: Thick sauces and tomatoes
Tomato paste, crushed tomatoes, thick marinara, cream soups, and nut butters are frequent Burn-message troublemakers.
The issue isn’t that tomatoes are “bad”it’s that thick mixtures can sit on the bottom and scorch before the pot
fully pressurizes.
- Layer smart: thin liquid first, then meats/veg, then thick ingredients on top.
- Don’t stir thick sauces into the bottom before cooking. Stir after pressure cooking instead.
- Use pot-in-pot (a smaller dish on a rack above water) for delicate or very thick mixtures.
4) Mistake: Skipping the Deglaze After Sautéing (Hello, Burn Notice)
Sauté mode is awesome for flavor. It’s also the number-one way to accidentally glue browned bits to the bottom of
the potbits that can trigger the Burn sensor once pressure cooking starts.
Why it happens
- You browned meat or onions, created flavorful fond, and then… never loosened it.
- You added thick ingredients right away, trapping browned bits against the hot bottom.
- The bottom overheats before enough steam forms.
How to avoid it
- Deglaze every time: after sautéing, add a splash of broth/water/wine and scrape the bottom
with a wooden spoon until it’s smooth. - Make sure the pot bottom is clear of stuck-on bits before you lock the lid.
- If a recipe includes tomato paste or thick sauce, add it last and keep it off the bottom.
5) Mistake: Overfilling (Especially with Beans, Grains, Pasta, or Foamy Foods)
The fill lines aren’t there for decoration. Overfilling can cause foaming foods to clog the steam pathways,
create messy sputtering during release, or lead to uneven cooking. The Instant Pot likes boundaries.
Why it happens
- We all love “one-pot meals,” but some foods expand dramatically.
- Starches and legumes can foam, bubble, and rise during pressure cooking.
- Too much volume can mean slower pressurizing and mushy results on top, undercooked on bottom.
How to avoid it
- Follow the max fill rules:
don’t go past 2/3 full for most foods.
For beans, rice, grains, oats, and pasta: keep it closer to 1/2 full if your manual recommends. - For oatmeal, split pea soup, beans, or anything foamy: consider a longer natural release and don’t rush the vent.
- If you need more servings, cook in batches. Your future self will thank you while cleaning fewer kitchen ceilings.
6) Mistake: Using the Wrong Pressure Release Method
Quick release isn’t “the fast button.” It’s a tool. Use it at the wrong time and you can end up with sputtering
starch, tough meat, or vegetables that look like they took a sad nap.
Why it happens
- Quick release can cause foamy foods (like beans or oats) to spray into the valve.
- Natural release continues cooking gently, which is great for big meatsbut can overcook tender veg.
- Recipes aren’t “bossy” about release for fun; it changes texture and safety.
How to avoid it
- Use natural release for:
large cuts of meat, soups, stews, beans, and starchy/foamy foods (helps prevent sputtering and keeps meat juicy). - Use quick release for:
most vegetables, seafood, and foods you don’t want to overcook. - Use a “hybrid” when a recipe calls for it: let it sit for 5–10 minutes naturally, then quick release.
Great for chicken breasts that need tenderness without turning into stringy sadness. - Safety: keep hands and face away from steam, and don’t vent under cabinets. Steam is not a skincare routine.
7) Mistake: Forgetting the Finish (Seasoning, Thickening, Crisping, and Texture)
Pressure cooking is amazing at getting food tender and cooked fast. It is not amazing at:
crisping skin, reducing sauces, or sprinkling in fresh herbs at the perfect moment like a TV chef.
That’s your joband it’s where a good meal becomes a great one.
Why it happens
- Pressure cooking traps moisture, so sauces can be thinner than stovetop versions.
- Flavors can taste muted if you don’t adjust salt/acid at the end.
- Ingredients like dairy and some cheeses can curdle if cooked under pressure (better added after).
How to avoid it
- Use sauté mode after pressure cooking to reduce and thicken sauces.
(Stir often; it’s fast.) - Finish with acid and freshness: lemon/lime juice, vinegar, chopped herbs, scallions, or a spoon of pesto.
- Add dairy (cream, milk, cheese) after pressure cooking, once the heat is lower. Stir in gently.
- For crispiness, use the oven broiler or an air fryer lid/accessory if you have onepressure cook to tender,
then crisp to perfection.
A Quick “No-Regrets” Instant Pot Checklist
- Seal check: ring seated + valve set to sealing.
- Liquid check: enough thin, water-based liquid for steam.
- Bottom check: deglazed, no stuck bits.
- Fill check: under max lines (lower for foamy foods).
- Timing check: remember pressurize + release time.
- Release check: match the recipe (quick vs natural).
- Finish check: reduce/season/crisp after cooking.
One Important Safety Detour: Instant Pot Is Not a Pressure Canner
This article is about everyday cooking, but this note matters: electric multi-cookers are not a substitute for a
tested pressure canner for low-acid foods. If you’re preserving foods like meat, broth, or vegetables, follow
trusted home food preservation guidance and use the right equipment. Your Instant Pot is a dinner heronot a
canning lab.
Kitchen Stories: The 7 Mistakes in the Wild (And How People Fixed Them)
You can read tips all day, but the lessons really stick when you’ve lived through a minor kitchen plot twist.
Here are common “real kitchen” experiences people run intowith the simple adjustments that saved future dinners.
The never-ending “ON” mystery. Someone sets a pot roast for 45 minutes, walks away, and comes back
to see the display still reading “ON.” The assumption: the pot is broken. The reality: the steam release valve is
venting, so pressure can’t build. Once they flipped to sealing and made sure the ring was seated, the float valve
popped up and the countdown finally started. The takeaway: if it won’t pressurize, don’t paniccheck the seal
before you write a dramatic review online.
The chili that triggered a Burn warning. This usually happens when tomato paste, thick crushed
tomatoes, or a chunky sauce is stirred directly onto the bottom after sautéing onions and beef. The browned bits
(fond) plus a thick sauce is basically the Instant Pot’s version of stepping on a LEGO. The fix is almost always:
deglaze with broth, scrape until smooth, then layer the thick tomato ingredients on top without stirring. After
cooking, stir everything together and use sauté mode for a few minutes to thicken if needed. Same recipe, totally
different outcome: no burn notice, no dinner tantrum.
The oatmeal volcano. Oatmeal, grits, and some bean dishes can foam a lot. If someone does a full
quick release the moment cooking ends, the vent may sputter starchy steam and fling tiny oat droplets like confetti.
The smarter move: let it naturally release for 10 minutes (or longer, depending on the recipe), then vent carefully.
Bonus trick: keep volume low (closer to half full) and consider pot-in-pot oatmeal to avoid foam drama entirely.
The takeaway: quick release is greatjust not for everything.
The “why is my chicken bland?” moment. Pressure cooking is efficient, but it can flatten flavors
if you don’t finish the dish. A common experience: shredded chicken cooks perfectly tender, but tastes like it only
read about seasoning in a book once. The fix is a finishing routine: taste, salt, add something bright (lemon, vinegar,
salsa verde), and stir in fresh herbs. If the cooking liquid is thin, sauté it down into a punchier sauce, then toss
the meat back in. Suddenly it tastes like you knew what you were doing the whole time.
The “but I wanted crispy!” surprise. People make wings, thighs, or carnitas and are shocked they’re
not crisp. It’s not user error; it’s physics. A sealed, steamy environment won’t brown like dry heat. The experienced
move is two-step cooking: pressure cook to tender, then crisp under the broiler or in an air fryer. That quick finishing
step turns “soft but tasty” into “restaurant-level texture,” and it’s often the difference between a good meal and a
repeat request.
The common thread in all these stories is simple: the Instant Pot is consistent. Once you learn its rulessteam needs
thin liquid, the seal must be correct, thick sauces belong on top, and finishing steps matteryou get reliable results.
And the best part? Your “mistakes” become your shortcuts. You’ll start cooking with calm confidence, like someone who
definitely does not own three different sealing rings labeled “curry,” “chili,” and “dessert.” Definitely not.
Conclusion: Make the Pot Work for You (Not Against You)
Instant Pot success isn’t about being a kitchen geniusit’s about avoiding a few predictable traps. Seal it correctly.
Use enough thin liquid. Deglaze after sautéing. Respect the fill lines. Choose the right release. Remember total time.
And always finish the dish like you mean it.
Do that, and your Instant Pot stops feeling like a moody appliance with opinions and starts acting like what it is:
a wildly useful electric pressure cooker that makes weeknight dinners easier, cheaper, and a lot more fun.
){kind=link}